Anytime 24/7—Hablamos Español

What Happens When You Reject an Insurance Settlement Offer?

After an accident, dealing with insurance companies can feel like a lot to handle. One of the big questions many people have is: what happens if you reject an insurance settlement offer? This decision can play a huge role in your financial recovery and overall peace of mind.

 

Here’s why you might want to turn down an offer, what happens next, and the steps to take if you decide to go that route.

What Is an Insurance Settlement?

An insurance settlement is an agreement where the insurer offers money to resolve a claim in exchange for the claimant releasing them from further responsibility related to an incident. The offer is typically based on an initial assessment of damages, which may include medical expenses, property damage, and lost wages.

When and Why Do Insurers Extend Offers?

Early Settlement Offers

Insurers tend to make low offers shortly after a claim is filed in hopes of settling quickly and saving money. They may count on claimants, especially those in financial trouble, to accept these amounts without knowing their full rights or the extent of their damages.

Post-Investigation Offers
Offers During Litigation

What Happens When You Reject an Insurance Settlement Offer?

Rejecting an insurance settlement offer can lead to a series of steps that may result in a better outcome for you. Here’s what typically happens next:

Negotiations Begin

When you reject the initial offer, you signal to the insurer that you're willing to negotiate for a fairer settlement; this opens the door for discussions in which you can provide more evidence, make counteroffers, and explain why you deserve a higher payout.

Counteroffers

After rejecting the first offer, you can propose a counteroffer that better reflects the extent of your damages. Support it with documentation, such as medical records and estimates for future expenses.

Demand Letter

If negotiations aren’t yielding results, your attorney may recommend sending a demand letter to the insurer; this letter explains exactly what you’re seeking and provides supporting evidence.

Mediation or Arbitration

If talks still don’t lead to a resolution, mediation or arbitration can offer a way to resolve the issue without going to court. Both options allow each side to present their cases and negotiate a settlement.

Filing a Lawsuit

If all else fails, you may need to file a lawsuit. While it can be a long, arduous process, it can lead to a larger settlement once the court makes a judgment.

Should I Accept the First Offer from an Insurance Company?

It’s best to think twice before accepting an insurance company's first settlement offer. The initial offer is often a lowball figure that doesn’t reflect the true value of your claim.

 

Reasons to Reject a Settlement Offer

Inadequate Compensation
Future Medical Needs
Non-Economic Damages
Pressure Tactics

Talking to a personal injury attorney can help determine whether the offer is fair and guide you through the negotiation process.

Settlement FAQs

How Long Do You Have to Accept a Settlement Offer?

The short answer is it depends on the insurer and the specifics of your case. Generally, you may have anywhere from a few days to several weeks to accept the offer — just be sure to respond within the deadline so you don’t miss your chance to get compensated.

How Long Does an Insurance Company Have to Settle a Claim in New York?
What Happens After You Accept a Settlement Offer?

Key Takeaways

Rejecting a settlement offer sends a message to the insurer that you’re prepared to negotiate for a more equitable settlement.

This is often necessary because initial offers are commonly lowball figures that don’t accurately represent the full value of your claim.

New York State does not impose a specific deadline for settling an insurance claim.

Unhappy With Your Settlement Offer? Contact Us Today!

If you’ve been offered a settlement that doesn’t feel fair, the team at Field Law Group is here to help. Our New York attorneys know firsthand how complicated personal injury claims can be and are available 24/7 to start working toward the compensation you deserve.

Contact us today or call 212-739-7278 to schedule a FREE consultation with our firm.

MILLIONS RECOVERED FOR OUR CLIENTS!

No Fees Unless We Get You Compensation.

Don't Wait Another Minute

Understanding your rights and how you can recover compensation under the law is important. At Field Law Group, there is no downtime. We are here for our clients whenever they need us.

Schedule Your FREE Consultation Today!

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

17 State Street, Floor 40
New York, New York 10004

Free Consultation

212.739.7278
Anytime 24/7
Hablamos Español

This website contains attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome, see Disclaimer | Designed & Developed by PostcardMania